I came across an
NPR segment that featured three authors discussing the current state of black relationships in 2010. The panel included Jimi Izrael who schizophrenically blamed black women for having standards that were both too low
and too high, Helena Andrews who admitted to having a self-described "bitchy," defensive behavior during failing relationships, and Hill Harper who promoted the importance of communication and understanding within black relationships. So basically, there was a male perspective, a female perspective, and a consensus-building perspective.
The conversation got contentious, particularly when Izrael called for black women to "get it together" and later dismissed Harper's book as being "too conciliatory." Another notable moment in the show came when a statistic was mentioned, claiming that in 1966, 84% of black children were born into two-parent households while in 2006, that number dropped to 31%. But what caught my attention most was the moderator's (unanswered) question revisited throughout the program: why do black men and women have difficulty forming intimate relationships?
Gee I wonder. Could it have been the media environment they were exposed to during their formative years? The panelists were in their late 20's and early-to-mid 30's. So perhaps the low standards promoted in lyrics like "
Ain't no n*gga like the one I got... Sleeps around but he gives me a lot" played a part. Or maybe half-assed attempts at romance like "
Meet me at the altar in your white dress. We ain't gettin' no younger, we might as well do it" had an influence. Perhaps the trivialization of marriage and parenthood in songs like "
Wifey" and "
Half on a Baby" jaded a few people. Maybe both men and women grew fearful of having unfaithful partners when they heard "
Friend of Mine," "
Say My Name," "
Get It on Tonite," and "
Stutter" flooding the airwaves. Or maybe the blatant acceptance of adultery in songs like "
Creep," "
Down Low," "
Yeah," and "
You're the One for Me" were to blame. Of course, the stupidity of denying infidelity while being caught red-handed ("
It Wasn't Me") would crystallize anyone's hesitance to take a chance on love.
Perhaps incendiary songs like "
No Scrubs" which discouraged low standards coupled with songs like "
Gangsta Lovin'" which
embraced low standards sent mixed signals as to what black women (should) want. Songs that promoted distrust of women ("
Poison") or that spewed the tried and true "men are dogs" sentiment ("
G.H.E.T.T.O.U.T.") may also have fanned the flames of discord between the sexes. If so, contentious songs like "
Be Careful" would only make matters worse.
Sure there were a few positive songs like "
Brotha" and "
Brown Sugar" that extolled the virtues of the opposite sex, but those were few and far in between. For the most part, there were songs like Mary J. Blige's gloomy "
Not Gon' Cry" as well as Toni Braxton's perennial songs about heartache, which likely put a damper on the excitement towards romance in general. Relationships would seem even less appealing if one expected to have to put up with the competition depicted in "
He's Mine" and "
Where My Girls At."
And that's just R&B. Add to that the countless rap songs and videos that objectified women and communicated the message that black men are thugs with only sex and violence on their minds and black women are sexual objects, bitches, hoes, and gold diggers--and you have a lot of mistrust and weariness on both sides.
Then consider all the romantic songs that predominated the airwaves like "
Forever My Lady" and the unrealistic "
Soon as I Get Home" and you have the primary reason why black women developed such high expectations in the first place. This, along with Disney's relentless "someday-my-prince-will-come" brainwashing and the "soul mate" mentality permeating throughout American popular culture, have most likely engineered a group of black women with high expectations who--probably from personal experiences reinforced by the themes in the aforementioned songs--sense a dearth of good black men, are pissed off about it, and thus develop the defensive "bitchy" posture that Andrews admits to.
At the other end of the spectrum, you have women with low expectations who'll put up with anything, giving the lower-achieving men little incentive to do better. The men that
are hard-working and put forth their best effort have to deal with a mix of jilted and jaded women whose expectations are too low, excessively selective women whose expectations are too high, and, yes, even some of those infamous gold diggers. These men will often adopt Izrael's schizophrenic assessment of black women and either stay single or date/marry outside of the race. And no matter which camp you're in, everyone's complaining, pointing the finger at someone else, and amplifying the feelings of discord on all sides.
To be sure, we did have sitcoms like
The Cosby Show that featured positive, healthy black relationships. But those were comedies whose depictions of black life would, arguably, be taken less seriously than in a dramatic context. Most of the dramas that were perceived as authentic depictions black life were played out in movies, few of which depicted healthy black relationships (e.g. "Waiting to Exhale," the various "In-the-Hood" movies, etc.). Relegating the positive black relationships to the less realistic sitcom context would only reinforce the notion that it is unrealistic--if not outright comical--to expect be in a good black relationship. And don't get me started on the droves of Jerry Springer and Maury Povich panelists who "represented" the most dysfunctional examples of black relationships that could be found (or contrived).
People often downplay the influence of the media, but you have to wonder if we'd be in a different place today had the messages been more positive and constructive. It doesn't help that polarizing conversations like the one in this NPR program--guised as "conversation starters"--only add fuel to the fire and widen the divide between the two camps. But hey, this program is part of the media too, so I guess they're just doing they're job, right? Keep feeding contention and discord into the minds of black men and women so that over the next 40 years we can reduce the aforementioned statistic from 31% to zero. That way, more black children can grow up in single-parent households with all the inherent social ramifications, including lower academic scores, higher incarceration rates, and lower overall health and wealth. Then we'll be even more susceptible to exploitation and subjugation, right? Right!
Carry on, media puppets. Carry on...